Illegal immigrant in jail after brutal brick killing in Croydon

Croydon Guardian: Umesh Chaudhari Umesh Chaudhari

An illegal immigrant who battered a father-of-two to death with a brick has been jailed indefinitely.

Rostram Ahmadi, 23, was jailed under the Mental Health Act at the Old Bailey today after pleading guilty to the manslaughter of Umesh Chaudhari just a few yards from the 41-year-old's house in Broad Green.

The court heard how Mr Chaudhari's wife and children rushed out of their house on Dennett Road to find Ahmadi repeatedly slamming a brick down on to his head in July last year.

It took the combined strength of two neighbours to wrestle the attacker away from the victim and pin him down on the floor until the police arrived.

Mr Chaudhari, who had come to the UK from Nepal in 2003 and worked 70 hours a week at Tesco in Addiscombe during the day and at a restaurant in the City of London at night, suffered multiple skull fractures and died.

Wife Rekha Sah said in a statement that he left for work at Tesco's earlier than usual to cover his boss' shift.

She said: "The incident happened outside the neighbour's house within five minutes of him leaving,"

Ahmadi claimed to be an 18 year-old refugee from Afghanistan but later said he was born in Iran in 1989.

He claimed asylum in the UK in 2007 but was refused an extension of his leave to remain in October 2010.

In February 2011 his appeal was dismissed and he should have left the country.

But three months later on May 30 last year he robbed a woman walking across Mitcham Common in south London.

He was released on bail and on July 6 last year attacked Mr Chaudhari.

Police officers arrived to find Ahmadi being restrained by three members of the public and Mr Chaudhari being cradled in the arms of his wife.

Witnesses described Ahmadi screaming threats even as the neighbours held him down him.

In custody he was seen to punch the walls and heard saying: "Do you know why I punched someone, because of Allah and jihad."

Psychiatrists later diagnosed Ahmadi as suffering from paranoid schizophrenia.

Ahmadi, also of Dennett Road, was charged with murder but pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter due to diminished responsibility.

He has previous convictions for battery and theft in 2010 and criminal damage in April 2011.

Judge Richard Marks QC ordered him to be detained indefinitely under sections 37 and 41 of the Mental Health Act.

The judge said: "The particular tragedy of these evens is compounded by the fact is you should not even have been in this country.

"Umesh Chaudhari was a good man. He was in every way a fine upstanding member of the community and a devoted family.

"The loss suffered by his wife and children cannot be overstated. The pain they have had to endure is difficult to comprehend.

"It is clear you continue to suffer from paranoid schizophrenia although you are responding to treatment. I have do doubt whatsoever that it was you very serious illness that explains how and why you did what you did."

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:07pm Mon 18 Jun 12

sureshtank says...

AS THE LAW STANDS IN HIS COUNTRY, EYE FOR EYE ,I FEEL HE SHOULD BE SENT TO HIS HOMELAND, AND NOT BURDEN THE BRITISH TAXPAYER !!!
AS THE LAW STANDS IN HIS COUNTRY, EYE FOR EYE ,I FEEL HE SHOULD BE SENT TO HIS HOMELAND, AND NOT BURDEN THE BRITISH TAXPAYER !!! sureshtank

12:22am Tue 19 Jun 12

Jonny English says...

WHY WAS HE NOT DEPORTED LAST JULY AFTER HE HAD ROBBED A WOMAN??? WHY WAS HE FREED EVEN THOUGH HE WAS ILLEGALLY IN THE UK?? AUTHORITIES REALLY HAVE LOST ALL CONTROL OVER IMIGRATION ...
WHY WAS HE NOT DEPORTED LAST JULY AFTER HE HAD ROBBED A WOMAN??? WHY WAS HE FREED EVEN THOUGH HE WAS ILLEGALLY IN THE UK?? AUTHORITIES REALLY HAVE LOST ALL CONTROL OVER IMIGRATION ... Jonny English

9:27am Tue 19 Jun 12

mr-bjp says...

As he was not deported when he should have been I hold the British Government responsible for this poor mans death. He WON'T be jailed indefinitely, as under the mental health act he could suddenly become sane and be released. If that happens he should be deported on the day of his release. This governemnt makes me sick with their lax immigration laws.
As he was not deported when he should have been I hold the British Government responsible for this poor mans death. He WON'T be jailed indefinitely, as under the mental health act he could suddenly become sane and be released. If that happens he should be deported on the day of his release. This governemnt makes me sick with their lax immigration laws. mr-bjp

8:18pm Tue 19 Jun 12

Charlotte L says...

The UKBA have absolutely got to start deporting people immediately upon arriving at a decision that a person cannot stay here, their attitude is incredibly sloppy & unprofessional, & it amazes me that this kind of bungling amateurism is allowed to continue.
The UKBA have absolutely got to start deporting people immediately upon arriving at a decision that a person cannot stay here, their attitude is incredibly sloppy & unprofessional, & it amazes me that this kind of bungling amateurism is allowed to continue. Charlotte L

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree